James Whitehead


Bade, William Frederic


Emporia, Kansas, March 7, 1917. Mr. William Fredrick Bade, 323 Marlborough St, Boston, Mass. My Dear Sir:- Your letter acknowledging receipt of John Muir matter received thia a-m- The paper containing article- "Recollections of John Muir" must have gone astray as I mailed it myself. I send you in envelope another copy as you will be more sure to get it in this way. But for the disclosures of John Muir his fathers severity with his children would never have been known. So far as I know, and I lived in that neighborhood for 30 years, no one thought or dreamed of Mr. Muir's punishing his children as John afterwards claimed he did. The difference between us was we told others about it, the Muir children never did, they bore their puishment in silence. This in my judgement was the reason his brother David sought to restrain him. Apropos to this - Ploubet in his Notes on the International S.S. Lessons" for 1915 has this to say relative to "The Solomon method" & its application to John Muir-Lesson Fen.21.,1915 on "The Death of Eli and his Sons" He that apareth the rod hateth his son", is as true to day as it ever was, if "rod" is interpreted as not merely "a switch" but as any kind of wise punishment. The famous naturalist, JOHN MUIR in his autobiography, represents his Scotch father as greatly overdoing the "rod" business. But JOHN MUIR turned out to be a wonderfully fine Man."— Prefaced with the remark- "The most of those who go astray from religious not all, could have been paved by wise restraint and punishment." You may have been told-though it nay not be of value or pertinent to your plan -Of Mr. Muirs investing largely in books, religious, & his traversing that entire country with horse & buggy and leaving them in the home of farmers who wore unable to purchase & after a stated period going over the same route collecting the same. The years passed on, the Muir family had scattered, one or two of the younger girls alone remained at home, so Mr. Muir sold the place known as "The Hickory Hill Farm". A sale was called at which the stock, farming impliments and part of the household furniture was offered for sale. An imense throng gathered. During the sale Mr. Muir stood near the auctioneer, if in his zeal to make good sale he mistated the facts Mr. Muir would say in his scotch dialect "Na, Na, mon tell the truth, tell the truth, dinna lie, it'l no pay, its an auld horse ye're seeling noo". A neighbor who had bought a horse asked me to accompany him when he went for the same, & some corn he had purchased also - Mr. Muir was directing the delivery of the goods or articles purchased. An old scotchman named John was weighing the grain, Mr M. happened to be near when John was, he thought, scrimping on the weight- "put on another ear John, put on another ear, its an aufa sin John, an aufa sin ta gie licht weight". And that to when the scales balanced & the weight correct. John as if to "get even" or the unmerited rebuke would put on two instead of one ear, at which Mr. Muir nodded approval & walked away. And it was from this man John Muir got his honesty & desire for a "square deal". It characterised Daniel Muir in ALL his dealings with his fellow man- Whlle this may not be of intront I take the liberty of submitting the same for your personal benefit & inforroation- Trusting you may receive thia letter with inclosure, (I would ask also, a list of books the publication of which you have supervised) I am very Sincerely Yours, James Whitehead


Emporia, KS

Date Original


Resource Identifier

MSS048 Va.10

Copyright Statement

Some material related to John Muir may be protected by the U.S. Copyright Law (Title 17, U.S.C.). Transmission or reproduction of materials protected by copyright beyond that allowed by fair use requires the written permission of the copyright owners. Responsibility for any use rests exclusively with the user.

Owning Institution

University of the Pacific Library Holt-Atherton Special Collections. Please contact this institution directly to obtain copies of the images or permission to publish or use them beyond educational purposes.