R[obert] U[nderwood] Johnson


John Muir


September 22, 1909R.W. GILDER,EDITOR.R.U.JOHNSON,ASSOCIATE DEITOR.C.C.BUEL.ASSISTANT EDITOR.My dear Muir:I hare your interesting letter of the 14th of September. Hurrah for the Taft-Muir excursion to the Yosemite!It was at the President's instance that I asked Ballinger to lunch with me at the Century Club to talk matters over. If he is sincere then we have found a sympathetic Secretary. When I showed him the photographs of the Hetch-Hetchy he was astonished at the beauty of the place and said that on the scenic argument he was with me. He told me that our opponents are quarreling among themselves; that one of the Interior Department men— a friend of Senator Flint— told the Secretary that there was a great deal of politics in this scheme.I sounded him on the revocation of the grant and he said he did not think that could be done but that possibly he might suspend its operation until Congresshad done something definite on the general subject.He gave me to understand that he would not go an an inch beyond the terns of the Garfield grant. He said he had refused to allow the supervisors to do04591 J. W. 2anything in the Hetch-Hetchy; that he had declined their permit to make a road up to Lake Eleanor because it would involve the cutting a big swath in the forest.When I proposed that you should go up with him he said he thought it would be better for him to take nobody from either side but to take some Washington officials who knew the region, two or three. After he had left the Club Alden Sampson told me that, all the same. Ballinger wished you to go with him; so perhaps you can have an excuse for another trip.When at Beverly I told The President.without naming the persons, that a distinguished constitutional lawyer and a Judge of the United States District Court had both confirmed my idea that an Act of Congress providing for doing something with a specific purpose could not be nullified by a subsequent Act of Congress of an administrative character, and the President said: "0n your statement of the matter I agreewith you." Now I am sure that the subsequent Act which Garfield invoked did not by any word change the purpose of the.Act of 1890 establishing the National Park. When I told this to Ballinger he seemed to agree, and I gathered from him that it would not be displeasing to him to have a friendly suit, so04591 J. M, 3to speak, instituted in the District of Columbia court enjoining him on this very basis from action under the Garfield grant.[illegible]Now I have already proposed for your consideration and that of Colby, without getting any response, that such a suit should be instituted by you alone or by other members of the Club. I should gladly join in, though I have no financial resources this year.I believe that Joseph H. Choate could be got to argue that question, and as it is one of public interest he perhaps would no's charge a large fee; perhaps none at all. But others perhaps could be got to do it in the public interest. Perhaps you and Colby may think that we would not gain much so long as the bill of the last Congressis to be reintroduced, but it seems to me that it would be a great gain all around for the various reserves_ if we could succeed. Of course Congress may do anything with the reserves— even to abolishing them all.I was very sorry about Harriman's death, for I know that he saved the day for us on the recession bill. I remember writing to him on that subject and invoking his aid and getting a nice note in return saying he would help.Don't forget that I think it indispensable04591 J. M. 4that you, and if possible Colby, should "be in Washington early in December to go before the Committee on Public Lands. I was told that our opponents are using money with correspondents in Washington; but the right will prevail.Faithfully yours,R. U. JohnsonAssociate Editor.Mr. John Muir.I have collected a lot of material about the Pioneers of Conservation but nothing from John Muir. What do you know about the origin of the old Yosemite park? Apparently Olmsted was the prime mover.04591


New York

Date Original

1909 Sep 22


Original letter dimensions: 26 x 20.5 cm.

Resource Identifier


File Identifier

Reel 18, Image 0754

Copyright Statement

Some letters written to John Muir may be protected by the U.S. Copyright Law (Title 17, U.S.C.). Transmission or reproduction of materials protected by copyright beyond that allowed by fair use requires the written permission of the copyright owners. Responsibility for any use rests exclusively with the user.

Owning Institution

University of the Pacific Library Holt-Atherton Special Collections. Please contact this institution directly to obtain copies of the images or permission to publish or use them beyond educational purposes.


4 pages



To view the content in your browser, please download Adobe Reader or, alternately,
you may Download the file to your hard drive.

NOTE: The latest versions of Adobe Reader do not support viewing PDF files within Firefox on Mac OS and if you are using a modern (Intel) Mac, there is no official plugin for viewing PDF files within the browser window.